Environmental Forensic Investigation of TCE, PCE, and Chlorinated Solvent Contamination
Project Overview
This environmental forensic investigation evaluated historical occupational and environmental exposure to volatile organic compounds (VOCs) associated with long-term industrial operations using accepted principles of environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, contaminant fate and transport, industrial hygiene, exposure assessment, and environmental forensics. The investigation integrated historical operational records, groundwater investigations, soil vapor studies, drinking water monitoring, engineering evaluations, environmental sampling, exposure reconstruction, and published scientific literature to characterize historical contaminant releases and potential human exposure through multiple environmental pathways. Rather than relying upon a single category of technical information, the investigation evaluated numerous independent datasets spanning several decades to develop a scientifically supported reconstruction of historical VOC contamination and associated occupational and environmental exposures.
The investigation focused on evaluating historical releases of chlorinated volatile organic compounds, including trichloroethylene (TCE), tetrachloroethylene (PCE), and related degradation products associated with industrial cleaning, degreasing, and manufacturing operations. Particular emphasis was placed on reconstructing historical contaminant sources, evaluating groundwater migration, characterizing soil vapor intrusion, assessing drinking water contamination, and estimating occupational inhalation, dermal, and ingestion exposures. Multiple environmental investigations, engineering reports, groundwater monitoring programs, soil vapor studies, exposure assessments, and historical technical documents were reviewed to develop a comprehensive understanding of contaminant occurrence, migration, and human exposure throughout the period of interest.
The investigation was performed using accepted principles of environmental forensics, environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, groundwater science, industrial hygiene, contaminant fate and transport, exposure science, and quantitative risk assessment. Available engineering documentation, groundwater monitoring data, drinking water records, soil vapor investigations, occupational work histories, environmental sampling results, exposure models, and peer-reviewed scientific literature were collectively evaluated to characterize contaminant sources, environmental transport, occupational exposure, and community impacts. Particular emphasis was placed on integrating groundwater contamination, vapor intrusion, environmental monitoring, and occupational exposure information into a unified scientific evaluation supported by multiple independent lines of evidence.
Because chlorinated solvent contamination frequently develops through decades of industrial use, environmental conditions were evaluated within the broader context of historical facility operations, groundwater flow, contaminant persistence, soil vapor migration, environmental remediation, and long-term occupational activities rather than isolated environmental sampling events alone. Evaluation of contaminant occurrence incorporated accepted scientific principles governing chlorinated solvent chemistry, groundwater transport, vapor migration, environmental persistence, drinking water exposure, inhalation exposure, dermal absorption, and cumulative human exposure. This multidisciplinary approach provides a scientifically reliable framework for reconstructing historical environmental conditions while remaining consistent with accepted principles of environmental forensics, environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, industrial hygiene, and quantitative exposure assessment.
Chemicals of Concern
The primary chemicals of concern evaluated during this investigation included trichloroethylene (TCE), tetrachloroethylene (PCE), and other chlorinated volatile organic compounds (VOCs) historically associated with industrial manufacturing, equipment maintenance, and solvent degreasing operations. These compounds have been widely used because of their excellent cleaning and degreasing properties; however, their volatility, persistence in groundwater, and potential adverse human health effects have made them among the most extensively investigated environmental contaminants. Evaluation of these historical releases required integration of environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, contaminant fate and transport, industrial hygiene, groundwater science, exposure assessment, and environmental forensics to characterize historical releases, environmental migration, and potential occupational and environmental exposure. The investigation incorporated historical environmental monitoring, engineering documentation, groundwater investigations, soil vapor studies, drinking water sampling, and published scientific literature to characterize contaminant occurrence throughout the study area.
Trichloroethylene (TCE) represented one of the principal contaminants evaluated because it was historically used as an industrial solvent for cleaning and degreasing metal components. Its widespread use over many years resulted in multiple potential exposure pathways involving inhalation of solvent vapors, dermal contact during handling, incidental ingestion through contaminated drinking water, and inhalation of contaminated soil vapor. Because TCE readily volatilizes from contaminated groundwater while also migrating within aquifer systems, the investigation evaluated both occupational exposure during active product use and environmental exposure associated with groundwater contamination and vapor intrusion. Historical work practices, environmental monitoring data, engineering information, and exposure reconstruction were collectively evaluated to characterize the duration and magnitude of TCE exposure.
Tetrachloroethylene (PCE) also represented an important chemical of concern because it was identified within groundwater, soil vapor, and historical environmental investigations associated with chlorinated solvent releases. As a dense non-aqueous phase liquid (DNAPL), PCE may migrate vertically through subsurface soils before dissolving into groundwater and generating long-term contaminant plumes capable of producing vapor intrusion and drinking water contamination. The investigation therefore evaluated historical groundwater monitoring data, soil vapor investigations, remedial system performance, and published scientific literature to characterize the occurrence, persistence, and environmental transport of PCE and its degradation products.
The investigation also considered additional chlorinated VOCs and degradation products identified during groundwater investigations, drinking water monitoring, and soil vapor evaluations. Because chlorinated solvent releases frequently produce complex mixtures of parent compounds and degradation products that evolve over time, environmental investigations incorporated analysis of multiple VOCs rather than individual contaminants alone. Historical environmental monitoring data, groundwater investigations, soil vapor extraction studies, and drinking water records were evaluated collectively to characterize contaminant occurrence, migration, and exposure potential throughout the period of interest.
A major component of the investigation involved evaluating multiple human exposure pathways associated with chlorinated solvent contamination. Potential exposure scenarios included occupational inhalation during solvent use, dermal contact with liquid degreasing products, ingestion of contaminated drinking water, inhalation of VOCs released from contaminated groundwater through soil vapor intrusion, and incidental contact with contaminated environmental media. Historical work practices, groundwater investigations, drinking water monitoring, exposure models, and environmental sampling were integrated to characterize cumulative exposure over extended periods of employment and environmental contact. Evaluation of these multiple pathways provided a comprehensive understanding of potential human exposure while remaining consistent with accepted principles of industrial hygiene and quantitative exposure assessment.
Finally, the investigation recognized that reliable evaluation of chlorinated solvent contamination requires integration of environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, groundwater science, industrial hygiene, environmental sampling, exposure science, and environmental forensics into a unified scientific framework. Published investigations consistently demonstrate that reconstruction of historical VOC exposure depends upon combining environmental monitoring data, groundwater investigations, soil vapor studies, engineering evaluations, occupational work histories, and quantitative exposure assessment rather than relying upon any individual dataset. Accordingly, this environmental forensic investigation integrated multiple independent sources of scientific information to characterize historical chlorinated solvent releases, environmental migration, and occupational and environmental exposure while remaining consistent with accepted principles of environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, industrial hygiene, and quantitative risk assessment.
Methods
The investigation was conducted using accepted principles of environmental forensics, environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, groundwater science, industrial hygiene, contaminant fate and transport, and quantitative exposure assessment. Because historical chlorinated solvent contamination developed through decades of industrial operations involving solvent use, groundwater migration, and environmental persistence, the evaluation integrated multiple independent sources of technical information to reconstruct historical contaminant releases and characterize occupational and environmental exposure. Rather than relying upon a single category of evidence, the investigation incorporated groundwater investigations, drinking water monitoring, soil vapor studies, engineering evaluations, environmental sampling, occupational work histories, exposure modeling, and published scientific literature to develop a scientifically supported reconstruction of historical VOC contamination. This multidisciplinary approach is consistent with accepted environmental consulting practices for evaluating historical chlorinated solvent releases and human exposure.
A substantial component of the investigation involved reconstructing historical contaminant sources using available engineering documentation, operational records, environmental investigations, and historical work practices. Industrial cleaning, degreasing, equipment maintenance, chemical handling, and waste management activities capable of releasing chlorinated solvents were evaluated together with historical environmental records describing contaminant occurrence and remedial activities. These evaluations established the scientific foundation for identifying historical release mechanisms and estimating the timing, duration, and magnitude of contaminant releases affecting groundwater, soil vapor, and occupational work environments.
Hydrogeologic evaluation represented a central component of the environmental investigation. Available groundwater investigations, monitoring well data, aquifer characteristics, groundwater flow information, soil boring logs, remedial investigation reports, and engineering evaluations were reviewed to characterize contaminant migration within the subsurface. Historical groundwater monitoring data were evaluated to determine the extent of chlorinated solvent plumes, identify long-term contaminant trends, and characterize migration pathways capable of affecting drinking water supplies and generating soil vapor intrusion. Integration of hydrogeologic information with groundwater monitoring substantially strengthened the environmental forensic evaluation by providing multiple independent lines of scientific evidence regarding contaminant transport.
The investigation also incorporated extensive evaluation of soil vapor intrusion and vapor-phase contaminant migration. Available soil vapor investigations, indoor air evaluations, vapor extraction pilot studies, and engineering performance data were reviewed to characterize vapor transport from contaminated groundwater into overlying soils and occupied work areas. Soil vapor extraction pilot testing, contaminant recovery evaluations, and remedial engineering studies were examined to evaluate contaminant persistence within the unsaturated zone and determine the effectiveness of remediation technologies for reducing long-term VOC concentrations. Comparison of engineering performance data with groundwater investigations and environmental sampling provided important scientific support for evaluating vapor migration and potential inhalation exposure.
Evaluation of occupational exposure formed another important component of the investigation. Historical work practices, deposition testimony, chemical product information, workplace activities, solvent handling procedures, frequency of chemical use, and estimated exposure durations were reviewed to characterize inhalation and dermal exposure associated with historical degreasing operations. Exposure reconstruction incorporated historical workplace conditions together with published toxicological information and accepted industrial hygiene methodologies to estimate potential occupational exposure over extended periods of employment. Occupational exposure evaluations were integrated with environmental exposure pathways to provide a comprehensive assessment of cumulative chlorinated solvent exposure.
The investigation further incorporated accepted principles of quantitative exposure assessment and human health risk evaluation. Historical groundwater concentrations, drinking water monitoring data, occupational exposure information, inhalation modeling, dermal exposure estimates, and published toxicological criteria were evaluated together to characterize cumulative exposure through ingestion, inhalation, and dermal contact. Consideration of multiple exposure pathways, contaminant persistence, duration of exposure, and historical environmental conditions provided a comprehensive assessment of long-term human exposure while remaining consistent with accepted federal risk assessment methodologies.
Finally, the investigation employed accepted principles of uncertainty evaluation that are fundamental to environmental forensic science. Historical contamination investigations inherently involve uncertainty because industrial operations, groundwater conditions, contaminant releases, remediation activities, and occupational work practices evolve over time. Rather than relying upon any single dataset, the investigation addressed these uncertainties through integration of historical operational records, groundwater investigations, soil vapor studies, engineering evaluations, environmental monitoring, occupational exposure reconstruction, and quantitative risk assessment into a comprehensive weight-of-evidence framework. This multidisciplinary approach provides a scientifically reliable basis for reconstructing historical chlorinated solvent contamination while remaining consistent with accepted principles of environmental forensics, environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, industrial hygiene, and quantitative exposure assessment.
Results
Review of the available technical documentation demonstrated that historical chlorinated solvent contamination could be evaluated using a scientifically defensible combination of historical source reconstruction, groundwater investigations, soil vapor evaluations, drinking water monitoring, engineering analyses, occupational exposure reconstruction, and quantitative risk assessment. Although individual environmental measurements represent conditions at a specific location and time, the investigation integrated multiple independent datasets spanning several decades to characterize contaminant releases, groundwater migration, vapor intrusion, occupational solvent exposure, and potential human health impacts. Collectively, these complementary sources of scientific information provided a comprehensive framework for reconstructing historical environmental conditions using accepted principles of environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, industrial hygiene, and environmental forensics.
One of the principal findings of the investigation was the strong agreement between historical solvent use, environmental monitoring, groundwater investigations, soil vapor studies, and occupational exposure reconstruction. Historical engineering records and work-practice evaluations identified long-term use of chlorinated solvent degreasers capable of generating inhalation, dermal, and environmental releases. Groundwater investigations documented persistent chlorinated solvent contamination within the subsurface, while soil vapor investigations demonstrated continued migration of VOCs through the unsaturated zone. Drinking water monitoring and exposure reconstruction further demonstrated that multiple exposure pathways existed over extended periods of industrial operation. Independent agreement among historical operational information, environmental sampling, groundwater investigations, and occupational exposure evaluations provided multiple lines of scientific evidence supporting reconstruction of historical chlorinated solvent exposure.
The investigation further demonstrated the importance of integrating hydrogeologic evaluation with groundwater monitoring and remedial engineering studies. Historical groundwater investigations identified chlorinated solvent plumes migrating within shallow aquifers, while engineering evaluations documented long-term remediation through groundwater extraction and soil vapor extraction technologies. Soil vapor extraction pilot testing demonstrated the continued presence of volatile contaminants within unsaturated soils despite previous remedial activities, illustrating the persistence of chlorinated solvents within complex subsurface environments. Comparison of remedial system performance with groundwater monitoring substantially strengthened the environmental forensic evaluation by providing independent confirmation of historical contaminant occurrence and migration.
Evaluation of occupational exposure also demonstrated the value of integrating historical work practices with environmental chemistry and exposure science. Historical occupational information documented routine use of chlorinated solvent products during equipment maintenance and cleaning operations, while product information and industrial hygiene evaluations characterized potential inhalation and dermal exposure associated with these activities. Exposure reconstruction further demonstrated that cumulative occupational exposure depended upon frequency of solvent use, duration of employment, work practices, ventilation conditions, and chemical handling procedures rather than isolated exposure events. Integration of occupational history with environmental monitoring and engineering evaluations therefore provided a more comprehensive assessment of historical workplace exposure than consideration of environmental sampling alone.
The investigation additionally demonstrated that reliable reconstruction of historical VOC exposure requires consideration of groundwater transport, contaminant persistence, vapor intrusion, occupational activities, drinking water exposure, and engineering controls rather than isolated environmental measurements. Groundwater investigations provided the scientific framework for evaluating contaminant migration, while soil vapor investigations characterized vapor transport into occupied areas and occupational exposure assessments quantified inhalation and dermal pathways. Integration of hydrogeology, industrial hygiene, environmental chemistry, and exposure science resulted in a more technically reliable evaluation of cumulative human exposure than reliance upon any individual dataset. These findings illustrate the importance of combining multiple scientific disciplines when evaluating complex chlorinated solvent contamination cases.
The quantitative exposure assessment further demonstrated the value of integrating occupational exposure, drinking water monitoring, environmental investigations, and accepted risk assessment methodologies when characterizing long-term human exposure. Historical contaminant concentrations measured in groundwater and drinking water were evaluated together with occupational inhalation and dermal exposure estimates to characterize cumulative exposure through multiple pathways. Consideration of workplace solvent use, groundwater contamination, soil vapor intrusion, and drinking water ingestion produced a comprehensive assessment of historical exposure while remaining consistent with accepted human health risk assessment principles.
Another important finding involved the successful integration of environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, industrial hygiene, groundwater investigations, soil vapor evaluations, engineering analyses, occupational exposure reconstruction, and quantitative risk assessment into a unified environmental forensic framework. No individual dataset independently characterized the complexity of historical chlorinated solvent contamination or resulting human exposure. However, when historical operational information, groundwater investigations, engineering evaluations, soil vapor studies, drinking water monitoring, occupational exposure analyses, and risk assessment were evaluated collectively, they provided a scientifically supported reconstruction of historical VOC releases and their environmental and occupational consequences. This multidisciplinary, weight-of-evidence approach represents a fundamental principle of modern environmental forensic investigations and provides a technically reliable framework for evaluating historical chlorinated solvent contamination affecting workers, groundwater resources, and surrounding environmental media.
Conclusions
The available technical documentation provides a comprehensive scientific foundation for evaluating historical chlorinated solvent contamination using accepted principles of environmental forensics, environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, groundwater science, industrial hygiene, contaminant fate and transport, and quantitative exposure assessment. Although investigations involving historical VOC contamination frequently require reconstruction of environmental conditions spanning several decades, the integration of historical operational records, groundwater investigations, soil vapor studies, engineering evaluations, environmental monitoring, occupational exposure reconstruction, and drinking water assessments provides a scientifically reliable framework for characterizing contaminant migration and evaluating cumulative human exposure. This multidisciplinary approach allows environmental professionals to reconstruct historical contamination using methodologies that are consistent with accepted scientific practice and widely recognized within the environmental consulting profession.
The investigation demonstrated that historical chlorinated solvent contamination is most reliably characterized when historical operational information, hydrogeologic analyses, groundwater monitoring, soil vapor investigations, occupational exposure evaluations, drinking water assessments, and engineering studies are evaluated collectively rather than independently. This weight-of-evidence approach reduces uncertainty by integrating complementary sources of scientific information and provides a technically supported basis for reconstructing historical contaminant releases and associated human exposure. Independent agreement among historical work practices, groundwater investigations, soil vapor studies, environmental monitoring, and exposure reconstruction substantially strengthens confidence in the environmental forensic evaluation while recognizing the complexity of long-term industrial solvent use and contaminant persistence.
The investigation further demonstrated the importance of evaluating chlorinated solvent contamination within the broader context of groundwater flow, contaminant persistence, vapor intrusion, remedial engineering, occupational activities, and drinking water system operations. Chlorinated solvents released during historical industrial operations may migrate through soil, dissolve into groundwater, volatilize into soil vapor, and generate multiple exposure pathways that persist for many years following the original release. Environmental forensic investigations that integrate hydrogeologic analyses, groundwater monitoring, soil vapor evaluations, occupational exposure reconstruction, engineering assessments, and environmental chemistry provide a more technically accurate understanding of contaminant migration than evaluations based upon isolated environmental measurements alone. Consideration of these multiple lines of evidence is therefore essential for developing scientifically defensible interpretations of historical environmental conditions and cumulative human exposure.
The investigation also demonstrated the value of integrating occupational exposure assessment with environmental investigations and quantitative human health risk assessment. Historical workplace activities, chemical handling practices, groundwater monitoring, drinking water investigations, soil vapor evaluations, and published toxicological information each contributed complementary scientific information regarding contaminant occurrence and potential exposure. Evaluation of inhalation, dermal, and ingestion pathways within a unified exposure assessment framework provided a comprehensive understanding of cumulative exposure while remaining consistent with accepted industrial hygiene and federal risk assessment methodologies. Integration of these multiple disciplines substantially strengthened the overall environmental forensic evaluation and provided a scientifically supported assessment of long-term occupational and environmental exposure.
More broadly, this investigation demonstrates how modern environmental consulting integrates environmental chemistry, hydrogeology, groundwater science, industrial hygiene, environmental engineering, contaminant fate and transport, quantitative exposure assessment, and environmental forensics to address complex chlorinated solvent contamination investigations. These multidisciplinary evaluations provide scientifically supported assessments of historical environmental conditions while remaining grounded in accepted hydrogeologic principles, engineering analyses, peer-reviewed scientific literature, environmental monitoring data, and objective technical evaluation. By combining historical source reconstruction, groundwater investigations, soil vapor studies, environmental monitoring, occupational exposure assessment, and quantitative risk assessment, environmental forensic investigations are able to develop reliable evaluations of chlorinated solvent contamination that are consistent with recognized scientific practice and contemporary environmental investigation methodologies.
This investigation was conducted under the direction of Dr. Paul Rosenfeld, an environmental scientist, environmental forensic expert, and exposure assessment specialist with more than twenty-five years of experience evaluating chlorinated solvent contamination, groundwater quality, vapor intrusion, industrial hygiene, environmental chemistry, contaminant fate and transport, drinking water contamination, and human health risk. Throughout his career, Dr. Rosenfeld has conducted investigations involving trichloroethylene (TCE), tetrachloroethylene (PCE), volatile organic compounds, PFAS, heavy metals, petroleum hydrocarbons, asbestos, dioxins, and numerous other environmental contaminants affecting occupational settings, residential communities, groundwater resources, ambient air quality, and drinking water supplies. His professional experience includes source-term reconstruction, groundwater investigations, environmental site assessments, quantitative exposure assessment, human health risk assessment, regulatory review, and expert witness testimony involving complex environmental contamination matters.
References
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. (2019). Toxicological Profile for Trichloroethylene (TCE). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry. (2021). Toxicological Profile for Tetrachloroethylene (PCE). U.S. Department of Health and Human Services.
Interstate Technology & Regulatory Council (ITRC). (2021). Vapor Intrusion Pathway: A Practical Guideline. Interstate Technology & Regulatory Council.
National Research Council. (2005). Contaminants in the Subsurface: Source Zone Assessment and Remediation. National Academies Press.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2015). Technical Guide for Assessing and Mitigating the Vapor Intrusion Pathway from Subsurface Vapor Sources to Indoor Air.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2020). Risk Evaluation for Trichloroethylene (TCE). Office of Chemical Safety and Pollution Prevention.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2024). Regional Screening Levels (RSLs) for Chemical Contaminants. Office of Land and Emergency Management.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2024). Exposure Factors Handbook. EPA/600/R-09/052F.
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. (2024). Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund (RAGS). Office of Superfund Remediation and Technology Innovation.
U.S. Geological Survey. (2023). Groundwater and Contaminant Transport in Glacial Aquifer Systems.
World Health Organization. (2023). Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality, 4th Edition (Updated). World Health Organization.